Overcoming the complicated burden with a personal path to recovery.
There is no question that mental health difficulties have become pervasive with providers in North American medical practices, with over 50% of physicians reporting significant symptoms of burnout. The pressure to care for patients, complete accurate medical records, and do everything in an efficient, timely manner can become overwhelming in and of itself. We cannot forget that medical professionals are also humans who often choose to form personal relationships, raise families, perform charitable work and champion community initiatives.
And that was before COVID-19. The number of US adults suffering from depression and anxiety has grown from 20 to 53 percent post-COVID, and is likely even higher for medical professionals, especially those on the front lines of fighting the pandemic.
It has been proposed that burnout is less connected to personal factors and more to external factors. Clearly, understanding burnout and findings ways to help clinicians is crucial to modern medical practice.
Healthcare professionals and especially physicians often hold themselves to such high standards that it is difficult to admit when they need help. The word “burnout” is practically a codeword of this mindset and philosophy. What does burnout really mean or represent for physicians? I have had the privilege of speaking with many physician friends and colleagues who openly talked about feelings of burnout. One doctor might say, “I’ve seen all my patients and now I need to spend two hours writing my notes and completing my electronic health record work.” A sympathetic colleague might respond, “Tell me about it! And I’m supposed to take my daughter to dance class in 45 minutes!” Later, both physicians hurry out of the office thinking, “Why am I working so hard? Should I reduce my practice time? Did I rush anything toward the end of the day?”
The expectation to perform both clinical and administrative functions flawlessly can result in immense pressure. Most physicians also know that burnout can lead to errors. It is perhaps not surprising then that this type of environment can lead to strong feelings of worry or fear particularly in the setting of a global pandemic. In the end, these emotions can sometimes represent anxiety, depression, and decreased work satisfaction. In severe cases, they sadly even lead to suicide. So, in essence burnout may just be a more palatable way of saying, “I’m having symptoms of anxiety or depression and don’t want to say it out loud.”
The first step to both understanding and addressing burnout is acknowledgement and designation of resources. Both domestic advocacy groups, like the National Academy of Medicine, and local medical groups have launched initiatives to improve clinician well-being..
Allocation of strategic funding to address burnout is more mixed. Having spoken to physicians from various organizations around the Bay Area, it is not uncommon to hear complaints like, “We need more funding for confidential well-being programs and not just continuing medical education (CME) classes. We need help and not just facts.” Hectic jobs require flexible solutions. Many physicians also prefer personal and more discreet therapies. I have personally taken advantage of retreat weekends and mindfulness instruction through the curricula offered by our Wellbeing Committee which has an annually designated budget. This commitment to flexibility and funding then prompts the next question: what should be offered to physicians facing burnout stressors?
A practical answer to where an organization should begin their efforts is to, “Start by doing what is necessary, then what is possible, and suddenly you are doing the impossible.” Many corporations, foundations, and medical groups have found it possible to offer services centered around mindfulness-based cognitive therapyand mindfulness-based stress reduction, such as formal psychology-focused in-person classes, counseling, and digital therapies. These classes, in particular, have been used for years in my community.
Two drawbacks to in-person approaches, however, include increased per capita costs and personal preference for remote care—the latter becoming even more evident during the COVID-19 pandemic. There are many novel self-directed solutions available that represent an alternative to traditional therapies, such as meditation-focused Calm App and therapist-supported distance instruction. Preliminary data shows that the therapist-supported digital programs can be specifically used to address physician burnout, anxiety, and depressive symptoms. Perhaps the flexibility of doing therapy anywhere you like, at any time you like, along with the support of a cohort and digital therapist combines the best of both worlds. There is no question that these services are necessary to prevent the escalation of burnout, so defining what is possible for each organization represents the beginning of the well-being journey.
Here are some steps individual physicians can take to address their own depression and anxiety issues:
Medical groups and employers can also take steps to help physicians experiencing burnout:
We must continue to both accept the use of terms like burnout and recognize that they are the gateway into the mindset of dedicated, hard-working professionals like physicians who may not want to accept the stigma associated with the diagnoses of depression and anxiety. Burnout is both a metaphor and a measurable psychological construct. It is real, complicated, and very personal. Ultimately, we must provide and promote a personal path to recovery for every healthcare professional suffering from burnout because it will not only heal the individual clinician but also generate better patient-outcomes, improve social relationships, reduce societal stigmas, and allow for the reclamation of workplace joy.
Dr. Vahamaki is a Family Medicine Physician; Medical Director, Palo Alto Medical Foundation; and a Scientific Advisor to Meru Health. He graduated from the Western University Health Science College of Osteopathic Medicine of The Pacific in 2003.