Blog|Articles|November 18, 2026

8 documentation gaps Medicare auditors flag most in physician claims

Fact checked by: Chris Mazzolini

Medicare's improper payment rate rose to 7.32 percent. These are the Medicare documentation requirements physician claims miss most.

Medicare paid out $33.96 billion in fiscal 2026 that it either shouldn't have or couldn't confirm it should have. The Original Medicare improper payment rate rose to 7.32 percent from 6.55 percent the year before, according to the CMS fiscal 2026 improper payments fact sheet released Nov. 16, 2026. Medicaid was worse: its rate hit 7.08 percent, and nearly 80 percent of its errors traced back to insufficient documentation.

Those figures don't count fraud. CMS says most improper payments come down to records that don't support the claim, such as a missing order, an unsigned certification or a note that backs a lower code than the one billed. But they do help set the agenda for the next round of reviews. Medicare administrative contractors pick targeted probe and educate topics partly from services with high national error rates, and the FY 2026 measurement covers claims from July 1, 2024, through June 30, 2025, before most of CMS' current anti-fraud push. The agency expects that push to show up in FY 2027 data, with bigger effects in FY 2028.

For physician practices, CMS' 2025 Medicare fee-for-service supplemental improper payment data, the most recent service-level breakdown, shows where reviewers find trouble. Insufficient documentation drove 58.4 percent of Part B improper payments, and incorrect coding another 18.8 percent. Here are eight gaps to close before a records request lands.


Related to this article