News|Articles|November 18, 2026

Know your market: AMA maps where single insurers dominate

Fact checked by: Keith A. Reynolds

AMA data on insurer market share by state and metro area offer practice leaders a clearer picture of who holds the leverage in payer negotiations.

If you’re a physician leader or practice administrator who manages payer contracts and who feels like there are few health insurers at the negotiating table, you’re right, according to the American Medical Association (AMA).

In 47% of U.S. metropolitan areas, a single insurer held at least half of the commercial health insurance market in 2025, and 95% of metro markets were highly concentrated, according to the 2026 update of “Competition in health insurance: A comprehensive study of U.S. markets,” released Nov. 17. It is AMA’s latest analysis of health insurance market conditions across states and cities.

“Health insurance markets across the country remain stubbornly concentrated, limiting competition and putting consumers at risk of higher costs and fewer choices,” AMA President Willie Underwood III, M.D., M.Sc., M.P.H., said in a news release.

The study covered 385 metropolitan areas, all 50 states and the District of Columbia, using 2025 enrollment data from Decision Resources Group. AMA economists José R. Guardado, Ph.D., and Carol K. Kane, Ph.D., measured concentration with the Herfindahl-Hirschman Index (HHI), the same measure federal antitrust agencies use to review mergers. An HHI above 1,800 means a market is highly concentrated; a single company with 100% of a market would score 10,000.

What concentration means at the contracting table

The report spells out why concentration matters to practices. If a practice cannot reach agreement with one insurer, the option of contracting with a rival gives the practice leverage. When that rival disappears or holds only a sliver of the market, the leverage shifts to the dominant insurer and puts downward pressure on payment.

Practice size compounds the problem. According to the report, 47% of physicians who provide patient care work in practices of 10 or fewer physicians, which leaves many with less bargaining power than the insurers they contract with. Physicians Practice has covered strategies for negotiating with payers, including steps for negotiating contracts and reimbursement rates in smaller practices.

Benchmarking your market

The report’s appendix lists the HHI and the two largest insurers for each state and metro area, giving managers a way to benchmark their local market. In the most concentrated metro areas, a single insurer holds 90% or more of the commercial or Medicare Advantage (MA) market.

Nationally, 97% of metro MA markets were highly concentrated. One insurer held at least half the market in 25% of metro areas. Average MA concentration rose 28 points in 2025, the first increase in the AMA’s comparison period, which begins in 2017.

Payer changes to watch

The report also documents shifts among insurers that could affect practices’ payer mix and contracting calendars:

  • Aetna (CVS Health) exited the Affordable Care Act exchanges in 2026, after holding 4% of exchange enrollment in 2025.
  • Cigna sold its Medicare business to Health Care Service Corp. and has exited the MA market.
  • Humana has exited the commercial market, while its MA enrollment has grown; it holds 17% of MA enrollment nationally.
  • Blue Cross Blue Shield insurers are consolidating across state lines. BCBS of Michigan acquired BCBS of Vermont, Arkansas BCBS and BCBS of North Dakota are merging with Cambia, and BCBS of Kansas City is merging with Highmark.
  • Exchange plans grew from 4% of commercial enrollment in 2014 to 14% in 2025. The authors expect that share to fall in 2026 with the expiration of enhanced premium tax credits.

Elevance Health had the largest commercial market share in 83 metro areas, more than any other insurer, followed by Health Care Service Corp. in 46, including 26 in Texas. Counted as a group, BCBS insurers held the largest share in 43 states and 84% of metro areas.

A long-running pattern

The share of highly concentrated commercial markets has stayed between 95% and 97% since 2014. Average concentration rose 87 points over that period, and 401 points when the exchanges are excluded, the report said, because falling concentration in the exchanges masked increases elsewhere.

The AMA said the findings support continued antitrust scrutiny of insurer mergers and vertical integration. The largest insurers also run the largest pharmacy benefit managers, and some employ physicians directly. UnitedHealth Group employs almost 10,000, according to the report.

AHIP, the health insurance industry’s trade group, has disputed past editions of the study, saying in a 2022 response that competition among insurers remains robust and that consolidation among hospitals, health systems and physicians is the greater concern.

“New research confirms that insurer consolidation can drive up premiums, underscoring the real economic consequences of market power,” Underwood said.

State and metro tables are available through the AMA Competition in Healthcare Research website.


Related to this article