News|Articles|November 20, 2026

Where practices have the fewest payer options: 10 states

Fact checked by: Keith A. Reynolds

American Medical Association data show the states with the least competition among health insurers.

Practice administrators who negotiate payer contracts know that the number of insurers in a market shapes what is possible at the table. In “Competition in health insurance: A comprehensive study of U.S. markets,” the 2026 report from the American Medical Association (AMA), 95% of metropolitan commercial markets were highly concentrated in 2025, and in 47% of metro areas, one insurer held at least half the market. The AMA measured concentration with the Herfindahl-Hirschman Index (HHI), a standard measure federal antitrust agencies use to review mergers. The HHI is the sum of each insurer’s squared market share, so a market served by a single insurer scores 10,000, and a score above 1,800 means a market is highly concentrated. This slideshow counts down the 10 states with the least competitive commercial markets, naming the two largest insurers in each, so practice leaders can see where a single payer holds the most sway.

For what the findings mean for payer contracting, read Physicians Practice’s analysis.


Related to this article