
‘I don’t know where my messages go’: What patients want from practice inboxes
Panelists at a National Academies meeting described how practices staff, schedule and use AI to handle patient messages, and what patients need to trust the process.
As patient portal messages increase, medical practices can handle them well by integrating electronic responses into staffing, schedules and technology, a panel of experts said.
Clinicians also need to remember that patients don’t ask for “asynchronous care.” They want to know whether they can message their doctor and what will happen when they do, a patient and family advocate said.
“Patients want to know if the message arrived and who has it, where it is. Can they track it?” said Libby Hoy, founder and CEO of Patient and Family Centered Care Partners (PFCCpartners).
Hoy spoke during a Nov. 12 panel on asynchronous primary care access at a public meeting of the
Who answers the messages?
Patient-authored portal messages rose about 150% from 2020 to 2025, Ganguli said, citing
What is the best way for physicians and other clinicians to respond?
At HealthLinc, Ramunno said each team centers on a physician and two nurse practitioners, with medical assistants, a nurse, a community health worker, a behavioral health therapist and a pharmacist around them. A patient who needs transportation help should hear from the community health worker, he said.
“Or their diabetes medicines need tinkering, give it to the pharmacist. They’re way better at it than I’m going to be, and they can pay attention and they can follow up,” Ramunno said.
HealthLinc’s pharmacists share a common inbox for medication refills and prior authorizations, so the work moves when one of them is seeing a patient. The lead clinician should tell patients plainly that a reply from a team member is still a reply from the team, he said.
“I don’t think you can do it with one person, no matter how many AI agents you have,” Ramunno said.
Knowing when a message thread should become a visit is harder in a health center, Ramunno said. Many FQHC patients have complex conditions, transportation problems or poor internet connections that rule out some telehealth.
How much time should the schedule hold?
At Firefly, nurses, nonclinical staff and AI assistants handle incoming chats first, routing refills, billing questions and clinical concerns to the right person, Greenberg said. Nurse practitioners and physicians have about 25% of their time set aside for asynchronous care, he said, and patients pick their care team when they sign up.
At Kaiser Permanente, clinicians in the office focus on the patients in front of them while nurses and a centralized group handle more urgent messages, Evans said.
Physicians and other clinicians may view asynchronous care as a reactive method of responding to patients. But messaging also makes proactive care easier, Greenberg said. Patients “are amazed when they get a proactive outreach from their provider,” and a message is far easier than chasing a patient by phone with a test result, he said.
Where does AI fit?
Kaiser uses AI to read each message, categorize it and route it to the right group, with red flags going straight to a nurse, Evans said. Message management continues through weekends.
Greenberg said AI is useful for gathering information and acting as a “pizza tracker,” confirming what the patient asked and saying who will handle it. Ramunno said HealthLinc is starting with appointment requests because clinical triage is still tricky.
Too often a message goes to a nurse who only tells the patient to make an appointment, Ramunno said. “OK, we didn’t use the nurse very efficiently there. The AI could do that, whether the appointment is telephonic or asynchronous or something,” he said, freeing the nurse for clinical work.
Hoy offered a caution because human clinicians still must build trust. A patient she works with praised a helpful nurse named Megan at her cardiology clinic. When she asked to meet Megan, she learned at her next visit that Megan was AI. The “lack of transparency, you can imagine, doesn’t feel so good,” Hoy said.
What do patients need to see?
Practices should set expectations about response time and urgency, show where a message is and tell patients when a message needs to become a visit.
“I can track when I order a pizza. I can track exactly where it is, but I don’t know where my messages go,” Hoy said, quoting one patient partner.
Even “we’re working on it” helps, Hoy said. Without that, patients lose faith in the channel. Ganguli compared it to basic email etiquette: Let the sender know the process has started.
Hoy urged practices to involve patients and family caregivers as designers of new message systems. Asked by Primary Care Standing Committee member Karen L. Fortuna, Ph.D., M.S.W., of the Geisel School of Medicine at Dartmouth, how to make sure patient input is used, Hoy said transparency is key. That includes explaining when a suggestion won’t be adopted, which might spark an iterative process that leads to designing something that works for the clinicians and patients, she said.
Related to this article








